#CBC: “As officers give all-clear on romaine E. coli outbreak, contamination stays a thriller ” #Toronto #Montreal #Calgary #Ottawa #Canada


This is an excerpt from Second Opinion, a weekly roundup of eclectic and under-the-radar well being and medical science information emailed to subscribers each Saturday morning. 

If you have not subscribed but, you are able to do that by clicking right here.

Something went terribly improper someplace between the fields of Yuma, Arizona and grocery retailer cabinets throughout North America. But precisely how doubtlessly lethal E.coli micro organism contaminated romaine lettuce twice in the previous few months stays a thriller.

In each circumstances, there have been no official product remembers. That’s as a result of investigators could not establish a particular product to recall. The street from discipline to meals retailer is difficult and they to this point haven’t been capable of hint exactly the place the lettuce got here from and what it encountered alongside the way in which.

On Wednesday the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) mentioned it was “examining all possibilities, including that contamination may have occurred at any point along the growing, harvesting, packaging and distribution chain before reaching consumers.”

It’s now clear that E. coli-contaminated lettuce reached many shoppers, together with some Canadians. Six individuals in 4 provinces turned contaminated with micro organism that’s genetically much like the E.coli outbreak that is been making headlines within the U.S. for greater than a month.

For each one case reported, there are normally 30 happening within the background, which aren’t reported.– Keith Warriner , meals scientist 

“One of the six has been hospitalized,” Dr. Howard Njoo, deputy chief public well being officer on the Public Health Agency of Canada, informed CBC News.

No Canadian deaths related to this outbreak have been reported. But again in December, two Canadians died after consuming romaine lettuce and 42 others bought sick. The victims included infants and the aged, and nearly half of them had been so sick they ended up within the hospital.

In the December outbreak, the victims all reported consuming romaine lettuce both at house or in ready salads from grocery shops, eating places and quick meals chains.

But when Canadian Food Inspection Agency officers examined lettuce for traces of E. coli, they discovered nothing.

Canada and U.S. outbreaks are genetically linked 

At the identical time late final yr, U.S. officers had been monitoring their very own outbreak of E. coli — a genetic match to the Canadian bug. Twenty-five individuals in 15 states bought sick and one individual died. FDA investigators may solely slim down the supply to “leafy greens.”

In the present outbreak, U.S. officers have reported one demise and 171 sicknesses, with practically half ending up within the hospital. 

In the seek for the supply of any meals contamination, the path shortly goes chilly. The clock begins ticking the second the meals is ingested, however it may possibly take days earlier than signs seem — and weeks for the sickness to be reported to well being authorities.

Only a fraction of the circumstances are ever formally recognized.

“For every one case reported, there are usually 30 going on in the background, which are not reported,” mentioned Keith Warriner, a meals security researcher on the University of Guelph.

University of Guelph meals scientist Keith Warriner believes the 2 incidents of E. coli-contaminated romaine lettuce are linked. (CBC)

By the time officers notice there’s an issue, the final traces of the wilted lettuce have been tossed, and any packaging has gone off for recycling or to the dump.

The solely remaining clues are the genetic fingerprints within the micro organism taken from contaminated sufferers. And as a result of the fingerprints within the two current outbreaks do not match, meals officers say the December and March outbreaks should not associated.  

Warriner is not so sure.

“This is not definitive evidence that the lettuce was not sourced from the same location,” mentioned Warriner. “Individual cattle can shed different genotypes of E. coli O157, and hence it is possible that a range of different strains contaminated the lettuce.”

Warriner additionally finds the timing between the 2 outbreaks attention-grabbing.

“I find it curious that there were 150 days between the outbreaks, which is around the time it takes to replant and grow a second crop of romaine lettuce,” he mentioned. “I think they are related.”

Contamination doubtless occurred in Yuma, Arizona 

Ground Zero for the contaminated romaine in each Canada and the U.S. is believed to be the Yuma rising area in Arizona, the place a lot of the winter romaine for the continent is sourced.

But that is so far as U.S. and Canadian investigators have gone within the hunt for the “smoking” lettuce leaf.

The FDA states that “the ongoing traceback investigation indicates that the illnesses associated with this outbreak cannot be explained by a single grower, harvester, processor or distributor.”

Most of the romaine lettuce grown in North America within the winter comes from Yuma, Arizona. (Peter Cowan/CBC)

One drawback is that the lettuce from completely different farms will get combined up. “We have found that a single production lot may contain romaine from multiple ranches, which makes the traceback more challenging,” learn the FDA report.

Warriner mentioned it could have been attainable for presidency officers to recall romaine from the Yuma area months in the past.

“I still believe back in December they should have had a recall of the romaine lettuce,” he mentioned. “I think they should have handled it differently.”

Mystery would possibly by no means be solved

The excellent news is that there isn’t any extra romaine from Yuma on retailer cabinets proper now. The FDA studies that the final romaine lettuce got here off the fields on April 16. Romaine solely lasts for 21 days.

It’s attainable that the romaine thriller won’t ever be solved, though meals security consultants have theories about how this sort of contamination may occur.

Lettuce in any a part of the world that is being produced is vulnerable to contamination and subsequently we actually cannot let down our guard.– Dr. Howard  Njoo

“It’s usually the irrigation water,” mentioned Warriner, as water for crops is commonly taken from streams close to areas the place cattle, sheep or different livestock could possibly be contaminated with E.coli micro organism.

“The Yuma area is dry and therefore dependent on irrigation,” Warriner mentioned. “A classic route is runoff from a manure heap into the river. Farmers take that water and irrigate the crops.”

Officials have declared the present outbreak over now that romaine lettuce is now not coming from the Yuma area. Still, shoppers are suggested to comply with protected food-handling practices. In the case of romaine lettuce, which means eradicating the outer leaves and rinsing the remainder.

“Lettuce in any part of the world that’s being produced is at risk of contamination and therefore we certainly can’t let down our guard,” mentioned Njoo.

To learn the complete Second Opinion e-newsletter each Saturday morning, subscribe.

Note: “Previously Published on: 2018-05-19 09:00:00, as ‘As officers give all-clear on romaine E. coli outbreak, contamination stays a thriller

‘ on CBC RADIO-CANADA. Here is a supply hyperlink for the Article’s Image(s) and Content”.

CBC Radio-Canada

Copyright © CBC Radio-Canada. All rights reserved. Distributed by the PressOcean Media. Contact the copyright holder directly for corrections or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material... Articles and commentaries that identify the PressOcean as the publisher are produced or commissioned by the PressOcean Media. To address comments or complaints, please Contact us.


No comments!

There are no comments yet, but you can be first to comment this article.

Leave reply

Only registered users can comment.