#GlobalNews: « Samsung must pay $539M to Apple for copying smartphone features, court says – National » #Toronto #Montreal #Calgary #Ottawa #Canada
The world’s prime smartphone rivals have been in courtroom over patents since 2011, when Apple filed a lawsuit alleging Samsung’s smartphones and tablets “slavishly” copied its merchandise. Samsung was discovered liable in a 2012 trial, however a disagreement over the quantity to be paid led to the present retrial over damages the place arguments ended on May 18.
Samsung beforehand paid Apple $399 million to compensate Apple for infringement of a number of the patents at problem within the case. The jury has been deliberating the case since final week.
Because of that credit score, if the decision is upheld on attraction it’ll end in Samsung making an extra fee to Apple of almost $140 million.
In an announcement, Apple stated it was happy that the members of the jury “agree that Samsungought to pay for copying our merchandise.”
“We believe deeply in the value of design,” Apple stated in its assertion. “This case has always been about more than money.”
Samsung didn’t instantly say whether or not it deliberate to attraction the decision however stated it was retaining “all options” to contest it.
“Today’s resolution flies within the face of a unanimous Supreme Court ruling in favor of Samsung on the scope of design patent damages,” Samsung stated in an announcement. “We will consider all options to obtain an outcome that does not hinder creativity and fair competition for all companies and consumers.”
The new jury verdict adopted a trial in San Jose, California, earlier than Judge Lucy Koh that centered on how a lot Samsung ought to pay for infringing Apple patents overlaying features of the iPhone’s design. The jury awarded Apple $533.three million for Samsung‘s violation of so-called design patents and $5.three million for the violation of so-called utility patents.
Apple this 12 months instructed jurors it was entitled to $1 billion in earnings Samsung created from promoting infringing telephones, saying the iPhone’s design was essential to their success.
Samsung sought to restrict damages to about $28 million, saying it ought to solely pay for earnings attributable to the elements of its telephones that infringed Apple patents.
Jurors within the earlier trial awarded $1.05 billion to Apple, which was later lowered.
Samsung paid $548 million to Apple in December 2015, together with $399 million for infringement of a number of the patents at problem on this week’s trial.
Apple’s case towards Samsung raised the query of whether or not the overall earnings from a product that infringes a design patent must be awarded if the patent applies solely to a element of the product, stated Sarah Burstein, a professor of patent legislation on the University of Oklahoma.
The verdict seems to be a compromise between Apple and Samsung‘s positions and doesn’t provide a lot readability on that query, stated Burstein, who predicted Samsung would attraction it to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
“This decision just means we are going to have more uncertainty,” Burstein stated. “Smart tech industry players are waiting to see what the Federal Circuit does. This is just one jury applying one test.”
Note: « Previously Published on: 2018-05-24 21:58:27, as ‘Samsung should pay $539M to Apple for copying smartphone options, courtroom says – National’ on GLOBALNEWS CANADA. Here is a supply hyperlink for the Article’s Image(s) and Content ».